When it comes to chainsaws, two names often rise to the forefront of discussions: Stihl and Husqvarna. Both have a rich history of delivering quality, but how do two of their mid-range offerings, the Stihl MS 271 and the Husqvarna 455, compare? Let’s dive into a head-to-head analysis.
1. Power and Engine
- Stihl MS 271: Boasts a 2.6 kW engine with a displacement of 50.2 cc.
- Husqvarna 455: Powered by a 3.5 hp engine with a slightly larger displacement at 55.5 cc.
Verdict: While the Husqvarna 455 takes a slight edge in terms of raw power, both models offer ample force for medium-duty tasks.
2. Fuel Efficiency and Emission
- Stihl MS 271: Utilizes Stihl’s advanced 2-MIX technology, which reduces fuel consumption and emissions.
- Husqvarna 455: Features the brand’s signature X-Torq system, similarly designed to decrease fuel consumption and exhaust emissions.
Verdict: Both brands focus on environmental friendliness, but real-world efficiency can vary based on use. It’s a tie in this category.
3. Weight and Handling
- Stihl MS 271: Weighs in at 5.6 kg (12.3 lbs) without fuel, bar, or chain.
- Husqvarna 455: A bit heftier at 6.4 kg (13.2 lbs) without fuel, bar, or chain.
Verdict: The Stihl MS 271 provides a lighter option, which may be preferable for prolonged use.
4. Bar Length
- Stihl MS 271: Offers versatility with recommended guide bar lengths ranging from 16 to 20 inches.
- Husqvarna 455: Comes standard with an 18-inch bar but can accommodate bars from 13 to 20 inches.
Verdict: Both models offer flexibility in bar length, suiting varied wood cutting needs.
5. Safety Features
- Stihl MS 271: Equipped with a chain brake and a master control lever. Its advanced anti-vibration system minimizes user fatigue.
- Husqvarna 455: Features a chain brake, inertia-activated chain brake system, and LowVib technology to reduce vibrations.
Verdict: Both chainsaws emphasize user safety and comfort, making them suitable for extended operations.
6. Maintenance and Accessibility
- Stihl MS 271: Employs a side-access chain tensioner and tool-free fuel caps.
- Husqvarna 455: Features a side-mounted chain tensioner and quick-release air filter.
Verdict: Both models provide user-friendly maintenance features, but the quick-release air filter on the Husqvarna 455 offers a slight advantage in rapid cleaning and replacement.
Conclusion
Choosing between the Stihl MS 271 and Husqvarna 455 largely depends on personal preference and specific needs. Both chainsaws provide reliability, power, and safety in their class. Those valuing a lighter weight might lean towards the Stihl, while those prioritizing easy maintenance might prefer the Husqvarna. Either way, both are solid choices for wood stove preparation and other medium-duty wood cutting tasks.